fbpx

Holmes: “If my fellow citizens want to go to Hell I will help them. It’s my job.” And he meant it.

In a letter to Harold Laski, Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes famously wrote:

I always say, as you know, that if my fellow citizens want to go to Hell I will help them. It’s my job.

And he meant it. Beyond such obvious examples of this philosophy, such as Buck v. Bell, where Justice Holmes upheld a law requiring the sterilization of those deemed mentally incompetent (even if there was no real evidence they were mentally incompetent), I was recently reminded of this quotation when I taught Giles v. Harris.

This key Civil Rights case was decided about 4 months after Holmes joined the Court (his 18th published opinion by my count). This case considered Alabama’s efforts to limit the franchise to those who owned property and could pass a literacy test (read and write a section of the United States Constitution). The plaintiffs asked the Court to add the names of many black citizens to the voting rolls who were eligible to vote before this requirement was imposed, but were not permitted to register.

Holmes denied his request because he said the voting regime was “fraudulent,” and it was not for the Court to add names to a fraudulent system. In other words, because the system is unfair, Holmes won’t make it more fair by adding names to an unfair system. Further, because the case was brought in equity, rather than as a constitutional challenge, it was not proper to invalidate it. In other words, after acknowledging the law was invalid, he was not willing to disturb it.

In contrast, Justice John Marshall Harlan dissented, finding the Court had jurisdiction to hear the issue, and would have found the law invalid.

As these are my views as to the jurisdiction of this Court, upon this record, I will not formulate and discuss my views upon the merits of this case. But to avoid misapprehension, I may add that my conviction is that, upon the facts alleged in the bill (if the record showed a sufficient value of the matter in dispute), the plaintiff is entitled to relief in respect of his right to be registered as a voter. I agree with MR. JUSTICE BREWER that it is competent for the courts to give relief in such cases as this.

As a result of the decision in Giles, southern states imposed a whole host of methods aimed at suppressing votes, without any limits under the 14th or 15th Amendments. In other words, “go to hell.”

Yet another case where Holmes and Harlan are on opposite sides of the issue of majority rule and constitutionally protected liberties.

Cross-Posted at JoshBlackman.com

Reader Discussion

Law & Liberty welcomes civil and lively discussion of its articles. Abusive comments will not be tolerated. We reserve the right to delete comments - or ban users - without notification or explanation.

on March 20, 2014 at 14:56:49 pm

Here's a related quote from Holmes that really ought to raise questions as to why he's so revered (as if Buck v. Bell weren't enough):

“The first requirement of a sound body of law is, that it should correspond with the actual feelings and demands of the community, whether right or wrong.” Oliver Wendell Holmes, The Common Law 36 (1881).

read full comment
Image of Aaron Gott
Aaron Gott
on February 17, 2016 at 17:30:08 pm

[…] and the courts won’t stop us from doing it. As Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes (a liberal icon) said, “if my fellow citizens want to go to Hell, I will help them.” Judges interpret the laws that […]

read full comment
Image of Full Court Press (Special Edition): On Justice Scalia’s Originalism | The Politic
Full Court Press (Special Edition): On Justice Scalia’s Originalism | The Politic
on July 18, 2019 at 10:06:33 am

[…] to play certain things beyond the reach of majority’s and above the vicissitudes of politics.” Oliver Wendell Holmes, a great progressive pin-up, said, “If the American people want to go to hell, I will help them, […]

read full comment
Image of George Will makes the conservative case against democracy
George Will makes the conservative case against democracy
on July 18, 2019 at 19:08:54 pm

[…] certain things beyond the reach of majority’s and above the vicissitudes of politics.” Oliver Wendell Holmes, a great progressive pin-up, said, “If the American people want to go to hell, I will help […]

read full comment
Image of George Will makes the conservative case against democracy – AVConnecting
George Will makes the conservative case against democracy – AVConnecting

Law & Liberty welcomes civil and lively discussion of its articles. Abusive comments will not be tolerated. We reserve the right to delete comments - or ban users - without notification or explanation.