fbpx

Woke Capitalism Is a Sign of Things to Come

Editor’s Note: This essay is part of a Law & Liberty Symposium on Woke Capital.

No one ever had trouble finding examples of corporate hypocrisy. Recent months seem to have brought a bounty. The same companies who submit to Chinese authorities have no problem resisting American ones. Corporations threaten boycotts against states whose legislatures pass laws restricting abortion and affirming sex differences and religious freedom. Wealthy CEOs join letters opposing the Trump administration’s efforts to limit illegal immigration. Technology giants that collaborate with China and inherently the Chinese military on AI and Internet censorship express qualms over working with the Pentagon.

The U.S. industries most obsequious to Chinese audiences present themselves as socially, culturally, and economically progressive at home. The National Basketball Association, Hollywood, Silicon Valley, and major financial institutions are exemplars of the “woke capitalism” that has transformed the business landscape in recent years. GM cannot meet the demands of 48,000 striking workers, but it wants you to know that it supports wind power and gender equity. GE suspended pension benefits, but remains a signatory to the U.N. Global Compact, is a highly rated workplace according to the Human Rights Campaign, and received a State Department award for “inclusive hiring in Saudi Arabia.”

What might look like a contradiction is actually a concurrence. Corporations are terrified by the specter of controversy that attracts scrutiny and regulation. Supporting Hongkongers invites rebuke. To be “woke” in America today does not. That is the difference between the celebration of Nike and the demonization of Chick-fil-A. Given the cultural power of the new progressivism, protests from conservatives weigh little in the balance.

Whether they are collaborating with the People’s Republic of China or publicizing efforts to achieve social justice in the United States, America’s woke capitalists are operating according to the instinct of self-preservation. This is not simply about the bottom line. It is about the legitimacy of the corporation in the global economy.

Cynics might ascribe the corporate embrace of woke capitalism to self-seeking. Social justice, they say, is merely a veneer that masks profits. That might be true. On September 5, “Activate: The Global Citizen Movement” premiered on the National Geographic channel. Produced in partnership with Procter & Gamble, and featuring Hugh Jackman, Gayle King, Pharrell Williams, Usher, and Darren Criss, the program is a parody of advertising masquerading as activism.

The episode on the “clean water crisis,” according to a multi-page advertorial in National Geographic, highlighted the fact that “844 million people around the world lack access to clean water.” Fortunately, “P&G, makers of Tide, introduced its ‘Children’s Safe Drinking Water” program in 2004 and since then, with the help of over 150 partners around the world, has provided more than 15 billion liters of clean water to people in need.” The episode “Ending Plastic Pollution” mentioned, “For over a decade, P&G, the makers of Head & Shoulders (H&S), has partnered with TerraCycle, a global recycling company on a mission to eliminate waste.” The episode “Social Justice Reform” is premised on the idea that “while some racial bias is conscious, much is unconscious and can be shaped by images in entertainment, advertising, and media.” That’s why “P&G believes in using their voice in advertising as a force for good by addressing important societal issues while ensuring positive, accurate portrayals of all people.” By contributing to P&G’s $68 billion in annual revenue, you too can help clean water, reduce plastic consumption, and foster racial justice.

Yet the cynics ignore the context in which businesses operate. Corporations don’t generate revenues automatically. They must provide a good or service that consumers want. And they must be relatively unmolested by the heavy hand of government. Procter & Gamble’s “Activate” may be well intentioned. It is also a form of insurance.

Houston Rockets general manager Daryl Morey probably didn’t think he was about to start a diplomatic incident when he Tweeted support for the Hong Kong protests on October 4. More fool he. Chinese social media accounts denounced him within moments. The Chinese Basketball Association, whose president Yao Ming played on the Rockets for about a decade, cut ties with the club. The Chinese consulate-general in Houston instructed the Rockets to “correct the error.” Morey deleted the Tweet.

The episode was an ugly demonstration of the insidious nature of corporate America’s relationship to Beijing. To guarantee safe returns, moguls, companies, and industries with investments in China are more than happy to toe the party line. A week before Morey made the “error” of advocating democracy, Michael Bloomberg, who holds an annual “New Economy Forum” in the Chinese capital, denied that Xi Jinping is a dictator. Earlier, when the trailer for the forthcoming Top Gun sequel made its debut, it did not take long for people to notice that the filmmakers had removed images of the Japanese and Taiwanese flags from the hero’s bomber jacket. The global box office now counts for more than the accurate representation of democratic allies.

Note, however, that the outrage over Morey’s Tweet started online. It then migrated to officialdom. The Chinese public is nationalistic. It becomes outraged at any perceived offense to national honor. American corporations have to take into account the attitudes, sympathies, and sensibilities of the Chinese consumer as much as the wishes of the Chinese government.

Consumer preferences also matter in the United States. Over the summer, Nike removed certain shoes in its Chinese stores because the designer expressed solidarity with Hongkongers. Around the same time, it withdrew from the market shoes carrying images of the Betsy Ross flag because Colin Kaepernick said they promoted white supremacy. In both cases the apparel company was acceding to consumer demands rather than risk government rebuke.

America’s corporations, forever in search of yield, cannot afford to ignore the reality that young consumers are drifting left. The Millennial generation is politically moderate compared to the rising Generation Z. The ideologies of diversity, equity, and inclusion, of intersectionality, of gender fluidity, and of environmentalism, secularism, racial justice, and assaultive speech have become the cultural mainstream (to the degree one exists). Woke capitalism isn’t a passing fad. It’s a sign of things to come.

Corporate behavior evinces the dominant beliefs of society. In China, those beliefs are not pluralistic. And that is increasingly the case in the United States.

Reader Discussion

Law & Liberty welcomes civil and lively discussion of its articles. Abusive comments will not be tolerated. We reserve the right to delete comments - or ban users - without notification or explanation.

on November 26, 2019 at 12:58:42 pm

The term "woke" means being conscious of racial and economic injustice. It is a hip version of the Marxist concept of "consciousness raising". Consciousness raising is the method by which any self-perceived oppressed group is taught to understand its condition and to be activated politically for revolutionary transformation of this condition. And it is the "vanguard" of intellectuals and media who will do the consciousness raising. But it is sociologically impossible to argue that one's consciousness is superior, or on a higher level, than the consciousness of ordinary people. If history teaches us anything, it is that the consequences of one's collective actions are unknowable and unforeseeable. Thus, no one "knows better" than anyone else.

read full comment
Image of Wayne Lusvardi
Wayne Lusvardi
on November 26, 2019 at 13:22:04 pm

I would define "woke" to mean being an ardent believer in the omnipresence and severity (in 2019!) of racial and economic and sex-based injustice in Western nations, having faith in the the omnipresence and severity of racial and economic and sex-based injustice in Western nations, and confessing that faith according to an Augsburg-like Confession written by the leading prelates of wokeness. Rallies and protests on behalf of wokeness resemble nothing so much as tent revivals.

read full comment
Image of QET
QET
on November 26, 2019 at 15:31:05 pm

"Identity (woke) is the theme that underlies many political (capital) phenomena today. We will not escape from thinking about ourselves and our society in identity terms. But we need to remember that the identities dwelling deep inside us are neither fixed nor necessarily given to us by our accidents of birth. Identity can be used to divide, but it can and has also been used to integrate. That in the end will be the remedy for the woke politics of the present."

read full comment
Image of Anthony
Anthony
on November 26, 2019 at 22:23:59 pm

[…] You think this stuff doesn’t matter? Read Matthew Continetti’s short piece on Woke Capitalism. It doesn’t conclude as standard conservative narratives do, by saying that companies are forcing […]

read full comment
Image of ‘Idea Laundering’ – Right Rant
‘Idea Laundering’ – Right Rant
on November 27, 2019 at 12:38:22 pm

[…] You Must Be A White Racist Cultural Imperialist – A. Chrenkoff at Spectator|Australia Woke Capitalism Is a Sign of Things to Come – Matthew Continetti at Law & Liberty How Trump Survives – Ross Douthat at The New […]

read full comment
Image of Secular News: Wednesday Edition – Big Pulpit
Secular News: Wednesday Edition – Big Pulpit
on November 30, 2019 at 17:26:21 pm

I like the analogy to "tent revivals". All this woke stuff is little more than a religion, and its high time the rest of us realized that. It proponents are seeking to proselytize their faith on the erst of us, and this proselytizing is just as dangerous as those seeking to advance some strange (and dangerous) cult.

read full comment
Image of Tom Terwilliger
Tom Terwilliger
on December 04, 2019 at 05:13:16 am

[…] Republished from Law & Liberty, November 26, 2019. […]

read full comment
Image of Woke Capitalism Is a Sign of Things to Come | Frontier Centre For Public Policy
Woke Capitalism Is a Sign of Things to Come | Frontier Centre For Public Policy
on December 04, 2019 at 15:30:50 pm

12/4/19 Post-script: https://www.thecollegefix.com/uc-davis-professor-under-fire-for-opposing-required-diversity-statements/

read full comment
Image of QET
QET
Trackbacks
on September 11, 2020 at 05:13:50 am

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 05:18:27 am

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 05:42:39 am

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 05:53:23 am

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 06:27:55 am

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 06:47:48 am

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 07:15:04 am

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 11:14:53 am

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 12:26:23 pm

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 11, 2020 at 19:35:54 pm

[…] the legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on September 20, 2020 at 00:02:09 am

[…] legitimacy of political, cultural, and economic institutions, including the corporation, has come into question. To ensure their survival, corporations must conform to the values and regulations of host […]

on November 02, 2020 at 06:33:06 am

[…] is more an effect than a cause. It has slowly dawned on Americans that we have fully entered a new period in which the Cold War coalitions have dissolved. The old consensus Murray examined in We Hold These […]

on November 02, 2020 at 17:31:45 pm

[…] than a trigger. It has slowly dawned on Americans that we now have absolutely entered a brand new period through which the Cold War coalitions have dissolved. The previous consensus Murray examined in We […]

Law & Liberty welcomes civil and lively discussion of its articles. Abusive comments will not be tolerated. We reserve the right to delete comments - or ban users - without notification or explanation.